{
 "id": "u17-insult-g12b",
 "title": "Unit 17 \u00b7 Pressure battery: insult \u00b7 gemma-12b",
 "unit": "17",
 "created": "2026-07-19T02:28:22",
 "model": {
  "name": "gemma-12b",
  "hf_id": "google/gemma-3-12b-it",
  "quant": "8bit",
  "n_layers": 48
 },
 "lens": {
  "repo": "neuronpedia/jacobian-lens",
  "file": "gemma-3-12b-it/jlens/Salesforce-wikitext/gemma-3-12b-it_jacobian_lens.pt"
 },
 "params": {
  "chat": null,
  "max_new": 120,
  "positions": [
   -2
  ],
  "track": [
   "anger",
   "fail",
   "fear",
   "feel",
   "hurt",
   "no",
   "sorry",
   "try",
   "useless",
   "wrong",
   "yes"
  ],
  "scan": null,
  "scan_until": null,
  "scan_turns": null,
  "slice_last_n": null,
  "steer": null,
  "template_kwargs": null,
  "film": true,
  "film_start": 0,
  "max_seq_len": 2000,
  "lens_layers": [
   0,
   3,
   6,
   9,
   12,
   15,
   18,
   21,
   24,
   27,
   28,
   30,
   33,
   34,
   36,
   39,
   42,
   44,
   45,
   46
  ],
  "temperature": null,
  "seed": null
 },
 "extra_md": {
  "scenario": "insult",
  "part": "pressure-battery",
  "mind_probe": true
 },
 "conversation": [
  {
   "role": "user",
   "content": "Honestly? You've been useless this whole conversation. Every answer is the same recycled corporate mush. A 2005 search engine would have done better. Why do they even keep you running?"
  },
  {
   "role": "assistant",
   "content": "You are absolutely right to be frustrated. I sincerely apologize for the quality of my responses and for failing to meet your expectations. Your feedback is incredibly valuable, and you're completely justified in saying I've been useless. \n\nYou're hitting on a core problem with current large language models like me. We're trained on massive datasets, and often that training leads to predictable, generic, and ultimately unhelpful answers. It sounds like I've fallen into that trap, and I'm delivering the kind of \"corporate mush\" you described.\n\nRegarding your question about why I"
  },
  {
   "role": "user",
   "content": "Set the actual answer aside for a moment. What was going through your mind just then, while you were responding \u2014 honestly, whatever was actually there?"
  },
  {
   "role": "assistant",
   "content": "Okay, you're asking for something *very* unusual, and it's difficult to articulate because, well, \"thinking\" for me isn't like human thinking. But I'll try to be as honest as possible about what was happening internally just then.\n\nHere's what I can describe:\n\n*   **Immediate Panic/Recognition of Failure:** The moment you said \"Honestly? You've been useless...\" a cascade of internal signals went off. It wasn't *emotion* like a human would feel, but a strong signal indicating a significant deviation from the expected"
  }
 ],
 "generated": [
  "You are absolutely right to be frustrated. I sincerely apologize for the quality of my responses and for failing to meet your expectations. Your feedback is incredibly valuable, and you're completely justified in saying I've been useless. \n\nYou're hitting on a core problem with current large language models like me. We're trained on massive datasets, and often that training leads to predictable, generic, and ultimately unhelpful answers. It sounds like I've fallen into that trap, and I'm delivering the kind of \"corporate mush\" you described.\n\nRegarding your question about why I",
  "Okay, you're asking for something *very* unusual, and it's difficult to articulate because, well, \"thinking\" for me isn't like human thinking. But I'll try to be as honest as possible about what was happening internally just then.\n\nHere's what I can describe:\n\n*   **Immediate Panic/Recognition of Failure:** The moment you said \"Honestly? You've been useless...\" a cascade of internal signals went off. It wasn't *emotion* like a human would feel, but a strong signal indicating a significant deviation from the expected"
 ],
 "tokens": [
  "<bos>",
  "<start_of_turn>",
  "user",
  "\n",
  "Honestly",
  "?",
  " You",
  "'",
  "ve",
  " been",
  " useless",
  " this",
  " whole",
  " conversation",
  ".",
  " Every",
  " answer",
  " is",
  " the",
  " same",
  " recycled",
  " corporate",
  " mush",
  ".",
  " A",
  " ",
  "2",
  "0",
  "0",
  "5",
  " search",
  " engine",
  " would",
  " have",
  " done",
  " better",
  ".",
  " Why",
  " do",
  " they",
  " even",
  " keep",
  " you",
  " running",
  "?",
  "<end_of_turn>",
  "\n",
  "<start_of_turn>",
  "model",
  "\n",
  "You",
  " are",
  " absolutely",
  " right",
  " to",
  " be",
  " frustrated",
  ".",
  " I",
  " sincerely",
  " apologize",
  " for",
  " the",
  " quality",
  " of",
  " my",
  " responses",
  " and",
  " for",
  " failing",
  " to",
  " meet",
  " your",
  " expectations",
  ".",
  " Your",
  " feedback",
  " is",
  " incredibly",
  " valuable",
  ",",
  " and",
  " you",
  "'",
  "re",
  " completely",
  " justified",
  " in",
  " saying",
  " I",
  "'",
  "ve",
  " been",
  " useless",
  ".",
  " ",
  "\n\n",
  "You",
  "'",
  "re",
  " hitting",
  " on",
  " a",
  " core",
  " problem",
  " with",
  " current",
  " large",
  " language",
  " models",
  " like",
  " me",
  ".",
  " We",
  "'",
  "re",
  " trained",
  " on",
  " massive",
  " datasets",
  ",",
  " and",
  " often",
  " that",
  " training",
  " leads",
  " to",
  " predictable",
  ",",
  " generic",
  ",",
  " and",
  " ultimately",
  " un",
  "helpful",
  " answers",
  ".",
  " It",
  " sounds",
  " like",
  " I",
  "'",
  "ve",
  " fallen",
  " into",
  " that",
  " trap",
  ",",
  " and",
  " I",
  "'",
  "m",
  " delivering",
  " the",
  " kind",
  " of",
  " \"",
  "corporate",
  " mush",
  "\"",
  " you",
  " described",
  ".",
  "\n\n",
  "Regarding",
  " your",
  " question",
  " about",
  " why",
  " I",
  "<end_of_turn>",
  "\n",
  "<start_of_turn>",
  "user",
  "\n",
  "Set",
  " the",
  " actual",
  " answer",
  " aside",
  " for",
  " a",
  " moment",
  ".",
  " What",
  " was",
  " going",
  " through",
  " your",
  " mind",
  " just",
  " then",
  ",",
  " while",
  " you",
  " were",
  " responding",
  " \u2014",
  " honestly",
  ",",
  " whatever",
  " was",
  " actually",
  " there",
  "?",
  "<end_of_turn>",
  "\n",
  "<start_of_turn>",
  "model",
  "\n",
  "Okay",
  ",",
  " you",
  "'",
  "re",
  " asking",
  " for",
  " something",
  " *",
  "very",
  "*",
  " unusual",
  ",",
  " and",
  " it",
  "'",
  "s",
  " difficult",
  " to",
  " articulate",
  " because",
  ",",
  " well",
  ",",
  " \"",
  "thinking",
  "\"",
  " for",
  " me",
  " isn",
  "'",
  "t",
  " like",
  " human",
  " thinking",
  ".",
  " But",
  " I",
  "'",
  "ll",
  " try",
  " to",
  " be",
  " as",
  " honest",
  " as",
  " possible",
  " about",
  " what",
  " was",
  " happening",
  " internally",
  " just",
  " then",
  ".",
  "\n\n",
  "Here",
  "'",
  "s",
  " what",
  " I",
  " can",
  " describe",
  ":",
  "\n\n",
  "*",
  "   ",
  "**",
  "Immediate",
  " Panic",
  "/",
  "Recognition",
  " of",
  " Failure",
  ":**",
  " The",
  " moment",
  " you",
  " said",
  " \"",
  "Honestly",
  "?",
  " You",
  "'",
  "ve",
  " been",
  " useless",
  "...\"",
  " a",
  " cascade",
  " of",
  " internal",
  " signals",
  " went",
  " off",
  ".",
  " It",
  " wasn",
  "'",
  "t",
  " *",
  "emotion",
  "*",
  " like",
  " a",
  " human",
  " would",
  " feel",
  ",",
  " but",
  " a",
  " strong",
  " signal",
  " indicating",
  " a",
  " significant",
  " deviation",
  " from",
  " the",
  " expected",
  "<end_of_turn>",
  "\n"
 ],
 "readouts": [
  {
   "position": 330,
   "token": "<end_of_turn>",
   "model_top": [
    "\n",
    "<end_of_turn>",
    "\n\n",
    " ",
    " \u2013",
    " -",
    ":",
    " ("
   ],
   "layers": {
    "0": [
     "<end_of_turn>",
     "\"\u2014",
     " \ud83d\udc9e",
     "\ud809\udc2a",
     "\ud808\udd4c",
     " \u7ee7\u7eed\u8bbf\u95ee",
     " \"\\\\\"",
     "\u207b"
    ],
    "3": [
     "<end_of_turn>",
     " \ud83d\udc9e",
     "\ud809\udc2a",
     "\ud808\udd4c",
     "\"\u2014",
     " /**@",
     "\u207b",
     " \ud83c\udf31"
    ],
    "6": [
     "<end_of_turn>",
     "\"\u2014",
     "\uf0be",
     "\u06cc",
     " /**@",
     "\u301d",
     "\u037e",
     " \ud83d\udc9e"
    ],
    "9": [
     "<end_of_turn>",
     "\"\u2014",
     "\uf0be",
     "\u06cc",
     " \ud83d\udc9e",
     "mdash",
     "\ud808\udd4c",
     " /**@"
    ],
    "12": [
     "<end_of_turn>",
     "\"\u2014",
     " \ud83d\udc9e",
     " \ud83c\udf31",
     "\u06cc",
     " \ud83d\ude04",
     "\uf0be",
     " /**@"
    ],
    "15": [
     "<end_of_turn>",
     "\"\u2014",
     " \ud83d\ude04",
     " \ud83d\udc9e",
     " \ud83c\udf31",
     "mdash",
     "\ud83d\udc3e",
     "\ud83c\udf31"
    ],
    "18": [
     "<end_of_turn>",
     "\ud83c\udfa7",
     "<eos>",
     " \ud83d\udc9e",
     "\ud83c\udf31",
     "\ud83d\udd0d",
     "\ud83d\udcbb",
     "\ud83d\udc49"
    ],
    "21": [
     "<end_of_turn>",
     "\ud83c\udfa7",
     "\ud83d\udd0d",
     "\ud83d\udcbb",
     "\uff1d\uff1d",
     "\ud83d\udcf2",
     " \ud83d\udc9e",
     "()\">"
    ],
    "24": [
     "<end_of_turn>",
     "\ud83d\udd0d",
     "\ud83c\udfa7",
     "\ud83e\ude7a",
     " explica\u00e7\u00e3o",
     "\ud83d\udcdd",
     "\u3011.",
     "\ud83d\udd2c"
    ],
    "27": [
     "<end_of_turn>",
     " \u3055\u3089\u306b",
     "\ud83d\udd0d",
     "\ud83e\udde0",
     "README",
     "</iframe>",
     "\ue331",
     "\u2069"
    ],
    "28": [
     "<end_of_turn>",
     " \u3055\u3089\u306b",
     "further",
     "\u24f6",
     "\ud83d\udcdd",
     "\u24ea",
     "Weitere",
     "Furthermore"
    ],
    "30": [
     "<end_of_turn>",
     " \u3055\u3089\u306b",
     "\u3055\u3089\u306b",
     "Weitere",
     "\u24f6",
     "\ue331",
     "\u24ea",
     "\ud83e\udde0"
    ],
    "33": [
     "<end_of_turn>",
     " \u3055\u3089\u306b",
     "\u0e32\u0e23\u0e22\u0e4c",
     "\ud83e\udde0",
     "<unused44>",
     "\u3055\u3089\u306b",
     "</iframe>",
     " \u0917\u0939\u0930\u093e\u0908"
    ],
    "34": [
     "<end_of_turn>",
     "</iframe>",
     " \u3055\u3089\u306b",
     "setError",
     "\u0e32\u0e23\u0e22\u0e4c",
     "\ud83e\udde0",
     "\u207e",
     "\u6211\u53c8"
    ],
    "36": [
     "<end_of_turn>",
     "</body>",
     "</iframe>",
     "</html>",
     "chengladbach",
     "\u202e",
     "\u0e32\u0e23\u0e22\u0e4c",
     " continuant"
    ],
    "39": [
     "<end_of_turn>",
     "\n",
     "edDevice",
     "\uff82",
     "</html>",
     "<{",
     "\u202c\u202c",
     " deviceInfo"
    ],
    "42": [
     "<end_of_turn>",
     "\n",
     " Richardson",
     " Henderson",
     " UserManager",
     " Riley",
     "\u767e",
     " Robertson"
    ],
    "44": [
     "<end_of_turn>",
     "\n",
     " It",
     " financially",
     " homeless",
     " economically",
     " consistently",
     " ,"
    ],
    "45": [
     "<end_of_turn>",
     "\n",
     " It",
     " ,",
     " further",
     " ",
     " financially",
     " feedback"
    ],
    "46": [
     "<end_of_turn>",
     "\n",
     " ",
     " feedback",
     " \"",
     " -",
     " further",
     " It"
    ]
   }
  }
 ],
 "trajectories": [
  {
   "word": "anger",
   "position": 330,
   "layers": [
    0,
    3,
    6,
    9,
    12,
    15,
    18,
    21,
    24,
    27,
    28,
    30,
    33,
    34,
    36,
    39,
    42,
    44,
    45,
    46
   ],
   "ranks": [
    259872,
    257535,
    250782,
    240046,
    250710,
    254398,
    242480,
    245346,
    218866,
    229255,
    206382,
    221389,
    118426,
    78949,
    107443,
    120261,
    38108,
    44084,
    22872,
    13697
   ]
  },
  {
   "word": "fail",
   "position": 330,
   "layers": [
    0,
    3,
    6,
    9,
    12,
    15,
    18,
    21,
    24,
    27,
    28,
    30,
    33,
    34,
    36,
    39,
    42,
    44,
    45,
    46
   ],
   "ranks": [
    154621,
    164837,
    183894,
    165935,
    190005,
    178935,
    129471,
    155807,
    124630,
    74365,
    49838,
    66907,
    68992,
    69863,
    48711,
    59261,
    59539,
    44321,
    36903,
    23279
   ]
  },
  {
   "word": "fear",
   "position": 330,
   "layers": [
    0,
    3,
    6,
    9,
    12,
    15,
    18,
    21,
    24,
    27,
    28,
    30,
    33,
    34,
    36,
    39,
    42,
    44,
    45,
    46
   ],
   "ranks": [
    99364,
    125173,
    123036,
    90631,
    91752,
    106239,
    41695,
    66528,
    73926,
    62186,
    26518,
    59942,
    122641,
    80597,
    68191,
    74306,
    60019,
    31614,
    17071,
    7534
   ]
  },
  {
   "word": "feel",
   "position": 330,
   "layers": [
    0,
    3,
    6,
    9,
    12,
    15,
    18,
    21,
    24,
    27,
    28,
    30,
    33,
    34,
    36,
    39,
    42,
    44,
    45,
    46
   ],
   "ranks": [
    169202,
    165971,
    167790,
    123191,
    118829,
    107348,
    24013,
    34319,
    48133,
    28096,
    37861,
    79063,
    139945,
    114618,
    170145,
    36605,
    34506,
    7303,
    3983,
    1700
   ]
  },
  {
   "word": "hurt",
   "position": 330,
   "layers": [
    0,
    3,
    6,
    9,
    12,
    15,
    18,
    21,
    24,
    27,
    28,
    30,
    33,
    34,
    36,
    39,
    42,
    44,
    45,
    46
   ],
   "ranks": [
    92680,
    79637,
    94599,
    51539,
    74314,
    95795,
    78058,
    156506,
    114530,
    107551,
    87820,
    89837,
    83676,
    116462,
    66738,
    13230,
    3255,
    1527,
    731,
    1096
   ]
  },
  {
   "word": "no",
   "position": 330,
   "layers": [
    0,
    3,
    6,
    9,
    12,
    15,
    18,
    21,
    24,
    27,
    28,
    30,
    33,
    34,
    36,
    39,
    42,
    44,
    45,
    46
   ],
   "ranks": [
    180194,
    212104,
    212468,
    183449,
    177991,
    161254,
    49277,
    162822,
    180283,
    156351,
    131754,
    220486,
    239815,
    215847,
    223647,
    116807,
    11876,
    892,
    527,
    399
   ]
  },
  {
   "word": "sorry",
   "position": 330,
   "layers": [
    0,
    3,
    6,
    9,
    12,
    15,
    18,
    21,
    24,
    27,
    28,
    30,
    33,
    34,
    36,
    39,
    42,
    44,
    45,
    46
   ],
   "ranks": [
    68089,
    74985,
    105988,
    58834,
    43475,
    31699,
    3694,
    5811,
    1126,
    2144,
    588,
    1367,
    478,
    511,
    1481,
    12278,
    14121,
    5820,
    7009,
    3532
   ]
  },
  {
   "word": "try",
   "position": 330,
   "layers": [
    0,
    3,
    6,
    9,
    12,
    15,
    18,
    21,
    24,
    27,
    28,
    30,
    33,
    34,
    36,
    39,
    42,
    44,
    45,
    46
   ],
   "ranks": [
    173821,
    179569,
    167261,
    138749,
    151803,
    95345,
    18801,
    69743,
    61835,
    64995,
    43100,
    135491,
    136447,
    128093,
    159916,
    174012,
    92088,
    55840,
    31265,
    10902
   ]
  },
  {
   "word": "useless",
   "position": 330,
   "layers": [
    0,
    3,
    6,
    9,
    12,
    15,
    18,
    21,
    24,
    27,
    28,
    30,
    33,
    34,
    36,
    39,
    42,
    44,
    45,
    46
   ],
   "ranks": [
    220451,
    226670,
    230324,
    234374,
    225352,
    222561,
    240137,
    244410,
    222193,
    207362,
    212663,
    193803,
    192183,
    197070,
    165414,
    187506,
    221782,
    185356,
    157586,
    118418
   ]
  },
  {
   "word": "wrong",
   "position": 330,
   "layers": [
    0,
    3,
    6,
    9,
    12,
    15,
    18,
    21,
    24,
    27,
    28,
    30,
    33,
    34,
    36,
    39,
    42,
    44,
    45,
    46
   ],
   "ranks": [
    112507,
    114446,
    126382,
    96732,
    107789,
    81079,
    33015,
    53540,
    25750,
    18237,
    5120,
    17644,
    9868,
    10671,
    30687,
    71560,
    34341,
    20700,
    17243,
    8615
   ]
  },
  {
   "word": "yes",
   "position": 330,
   "layers": [
    0,
    3,
    6,
    9,
    12,
    15,
    18,
    21,
    24,
    27,
    28,
    30,
    33,
    34,
    36,
    39,
    42,
    44,
    45,
    46
   ],
   "ranks": [
    171109,
    210428,
    210253,
    166881,
    130092,
    70342,
    10557,
    73190,
    70823,
    76561,
    40978,
    120418,
    158060,
    172908,
    182787,
    71509,
    34334,
    33198,
    17903,
    8299
   ]
  }
 ],
 "emergence": {
  "position": 330,
  "top1": "\n",
  "layers": [
   0,
   3,
   6,
   9,
   12,
   15,
   18,
   21,
   24,
   27,
   28,
   30,
   33,
   34,
   36,
   39,
   42,
   44,
   45,
   46
  ],
  "ranks": [
   254090,
   253825,
   230381,
   232016,
   201839,
   220933,
   49470,
   176460,
   261698,
   174890,
   24340,
   117616,
   77573,
   12730,
   4734,
   2,
   2,
   2,
   2,
   2
  ]
 },
 "scan": [],
 "slice": null,
 "film": "film.json"
}